Zohaib Ahmed

Who Won in Syria? Analyzing the Aftermath of the Civil War

The Syrian Civil War, which began in 2011, has been one of the most devastating and complex conflicts in recent history. Over the years, it has drawn in a multitude of international actors, internal factions, and proxy wars. With Assad’s regime finally collapsing in December 2024, many are asking: Who truly won in Syria?

Image Source: The Newyorker

The war saw millions of lives lost, and entire cities were destroyed. The conflict was not just about territorial control; it was a battle over identity, ideology, and regional influence. Now that the dust has settled, it’s clear that there isn’t just one clear-cut “winner.” The situation is far more complicated, with multiple groups emerging with different levels of power, influence, and control.

The Decline of Assad: Was the Regime a Winner?

For over two decades, Bashar al-Assad ruled Syria with an iron fist. His regime was entrenched in corruption, human rights abuses, and repression. But his government managed to withstand the opposition for much longer than many anticipated, primarily due to the backing of Russia and Iran.

However, Assad’s eventual fall marks the end of his regime, making it difficult to categorize his government as a winner. Despite securing the capital, Damascus, and retaining control of significant portions of Syria, the collapse reveals just how fragile his hold on power was. His departure has left a power vacuum in the country, signaling the end of an era for the Assad family.

Ha’yat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS): The Unlikely Victor?

In an unexpected twist, Ha’yat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS), a radical Islamist group once aligned with al-Qaeda, has emerged as one of the key players in the post-Assad era. HTS took advantage of the chaos caused by the civil war, gradually consolidating power in the northwest region of Syria, particularly in Idlib. By the time Assad’s regime collapsed, HTS, along with its Turkish-backed allies, seized control of large portions of the country.

HTS’s leader, Abu Mohammed al-Jolani, has positioned himself as a political figure who is keen on governing and rebuilding Syria. While HTS claims to represent the aspirations of the Syrian people, they remain an Islamist group with a controversial record. Their harsh rule, including accusations of human rights violations, makes their claim to victory a double-edged sword. Still, HTS’s rise to power symbolizes a significant shift in Syria’s future, as the group now controls a large territory with substantial influence.

Turkey: The Real Geopolitical Winner?

On the international stage, Turkey emerges as one of the biggest geopolitical winners of the Syrian conflict. Throughout the war, Turkey, led by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, positioned itself as a staunch opponent of the Assad regime. Erdogan provided military and logistical support to rebel groups, including those aligned with HTS, while also launching multiple operations in Syria to secure its border from Kurdish forces.

With Assad’s fall, Turkey is now in a strong position to influence Syria’s future. The Turkish-backed Syrian National Army (SNA) now controls parts of northern Syria, including key border areas. Turkey also has the potential to broker a peace settlement and shape Syria’s future political order. Despite challenges, including tensions with HTS and Kurdish forces, Turkey’s influence in post-Assad Syria will likely be critical in determining the region’s stability.

The Kurds: Gaining Ground but Facing Challenges

The Kurdish forces, particularly the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), have been among the most organized and effective groups fighting against both Assad and ISIS. The Kurds gained significant territorial control in northern Syria, including key cities such as Manbij and Raqqa, with the help of U.S. support. For the Kurds, the collapse of Assad’s regime presents an opportunity to expand their influence, particularly in the northeastern regions.

However, the situation for the Kurds is far from straightforward. Turkey views Kurdish forces as a direct threat to its national security, considering the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) an insurgent group. As a result, Turkey has made several incursions into northern Syria, aiming to dismantle Kurdish control in the region. The Kurds now face the challenge of balancing their ambitions for autonomy with the need to navigate complex relationships with other regional powers, including Turkey and the U.S.

The United States: A Shifting Role in Syria

While the U.S. supported various factions in the Syrian Civil War, including the Kurdish SDF and moderate rebel groups, its long-term strategy was often unclear. The U.S. has been critical of Assad’s regime but has also distanced itself from direct intervention. Following Assad’s fall, the U.S. finds itself at a crossroads. The U.S. could potentially exert influence in Syria through its alliances with Kurdish forces and other opposition groups.

However, the rise of HTS and the potential for a fragmented state mean that the U.S.’s involvement could become more complicated. The possibility of a proxy war between regional powers such as Turkey, Iran, and Saudi Arabia may draw the U.S. into further entanglements in the region, even as the country’s focus shifts away from direct military involvement in Syria.

Iran and Russia: Regional Losers?

Iran and Russia, the two primary international backers of the Assad regime, were dealt a major blow by the regime’s collapse. Both nations invested heavily in military and economic support for Assad. Iran’s role in the Syrian conflict, particularly its ties to Hezbollah and Shiite militias, was central to the ongoing resistance against opposition forces.

Yet, despite their extensive support, both countries were unable to prevent Assad’s downfall. Iran’s loss is particularly acute because Syria was a critical part of its “Shiite Crescent,” which extends from Iran through Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon. Losing influence in Syria weakens Iran’s strategic foothold in the Middle East.

Similarly, Russia’s involvement in Syria was seen as a crucial geopolitical maneuver to reassert its dominance in the Middle East. The failure of Assad’s regime could represent a significant setback for Russian ambitions in the region.

The People of Syria: The True Victims

While the external powers and factions battle for dominance, it’s important to remember the true losers of the conflict: the Syrian people. Over 500,000 lives were lost during the war, and millions of Syrians were displaced, both internally and as refugees abroad. Infrastructure was decimated, entire neighborhoods reduced to rubble, and the country’s economy has been shattered.

Despite the complex geopolitical struggles and shifting alliances, Syrians are left to pick up the pieces of their war-torn homeland. While new political structures emerge, the road to peace and rebuilding will be long and fraught with challenges.

Conclusion: A Fractured and Uncertain Future

So, who won in Syria? The answer is far from clear. While HTS and Turkey are positioned to play significant roles in shaping Syria’s future, the true victors in the traditional sense—those who will rebuild and unify Syria—remain elusive. The war is over, but the struggle for Syria’s future is far from settled. The country is fractured, with competing factions, international powers, and local actors all vying for control.

Ultimately, Syria’s future hinges on the ability of its people to unite, rebuild, and form a new government that reflects the diverse and complex nature of its society. Until then, the question of who truly “won” in Syria remains a matter of perspective—shaped by political, military, and ideological interests across the Middle East and beyond.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *