Zohaib Ahmed

Demilitarizing Palestine: Ceasefire Illusion or Peaceful Solution?

The Global Push for Ceasefire — But at What Cost?

In mid-2025, a flurry of diplomatic activity from Cairo to Doha to Istanbul reveals a united push — from the United States to several Arab nations — to enforce a ceasefire in the Israel-Gaza conflict. At the center of this plan lies a critical clause: the demilitarization of Hamas.

Western and Arab negotiators argue that peace demands the disarmament of all militant factions within Palestine. Hamas, in an uncharacteristically pragmatic tone, has reportedly shown a willingness to accept this on the condition of a legitimate and enforceable two-state solution.

But the real question remains: Is this even possible?

The Illusion of Disarmament Without Justice

Before we talk about rockets and rifles, let’s look at the battlefield most people ignore: the West Bank.

Since October 7, 2023 — the day Israel’s war on Gaza began — the West Bank has seen one of its bloodiest and most destabilizing periods in recent history:

  • 🔺 Over 950 Palestinians killed (including women and children)
  • 🔺 3,721 documented settler attacks, often carried out with the tacit or explicit backing of Israeli soldiers
  • 🔺 414 settler attacks in the first half of 2025 alone
  • 🔺 Over 20 new illegal settlements have been approved
  • 🔺 Thousands of new settler housing units are being built on occupied Palestinian land

All of this has happened without Hamas firing a single rocket from the West Bank.

Let that sink in.

Disarming Hamas — While the West Bank Burns?

The Israeli state and its allies claim that Hamas’ weapons are the core issue — the barrier to peace. But this assertion collapses when viewed alongside what’s happening in the West Bank, a territory supposedly under the control of the “peaceful” Palestinian Authority (PA).

Yet the PA, despite being unarmed and internationally recognized, has been unable to protect its own citizens from:

  • Land confiscation
  • Settler terrorism
  • Extrajudicial killings
  • Checkpoint violence
  • Economic strangulation

So what does history teach us?

A Glimpse into Oslo’s Ghost

The 1993 Oslo Accords were hailed as the beginning of peace. In return for recognition of Israel and renunciation of armed struggle, the Palestinian Authority was promised autonomy and a path to statehood.

More than 30 years later, there is no state, no sovereignty — just a deeply fragmented Palestinian governance structure and a 700-kilometer-long separation wall that has choked Palestinian movement, economy, and dignity.

In Gaza, Israel unilaterally “withdrew” in 2005 — only to impose a crippling blockade ever since. When Hamas took control in 2007, after winning an election, it inherited not just governance, but total isolation — leading to four wars and ongoing sieges.

So, does history support the idea that disarming resistance leads to peace?

Or does it show that disarmament without justice leads to colonization without resistance?

Hamas’ Strategic Gamble — and What It Really Wants

Despite its reputation in the West, Hamas is not a monolithic terror group. It is part military, part political, and part social movement — and it has shown strategic adaptability when cornered.

Recent reports suggest Hamas is open to handing over Gaza’s civilian rule to a reformed Palestinian Authority or technocratic government — provided two core guarantees:

  1. A legitimate and enforceable path to a two-state solution
  2. International guarantees against further Israeli expansionism

This is not unprecedented. In 2017, Hamas released a revised charter that accepted the idea of a Palestinian state based on 1967 borders. In 2021, it participated in indirect ceasefire negotiations through Egypt and Qatar. In 2024–25, it has signaled openness to compromise if the endgame is real sovereignty, not subjugation.

Disarming Hamas: A Misdiagnosis of the Problem

Let’s be blunt: Hamas is a symptom—not the disease.

Its rise was a direct consequence of the Oslo Accords’ failure, the collapse of Fatah’s credibility, and Israel’s continuous land grabs, siege policies, and ethnic cleansing campaigns. Asking Hamas to disarm before any binding guarantees of statehood, borders, or sovereignty is like asking the patient to stop coughing while ignoring the cancer.

Worse still, this approach pretends that Israel is a neutral actor. It conveniently forgets that Israel has repeatedly sabotaged peace initiatives, assassinated Palestinian negotiators, and continued its illegal occupation for 57+ years.


Two-State Solution? Let’s Be Honest

The “two-state solution” remains a global diplomatic fantasy—invoked when convenient, discarded when action is required.

  • East Jerusalem, supposed to be the Palestinian capital, has been annexed by Israel.
  • Area C of the West Bank, over 60% of its land, is effectively controlled by Israel.
  • There are now more than 700,000 Israeli settlers in the West Bank and East Jerusalem—making any contiguous Palestinian state nearly impossible.

How does one build a sovereign state around military checkpoints, walls, and armed settler enclaves?


The Right Sequence: Reform First, Disarmament Later

If peace is truly the goal—and not just the pacification of Palestinians—the international community must flip the script:

  1. Reform the Palestinian Authority: The PA has become a deeply corrupt, unrepresentative body. Only through democratic reforms and inclusive elections can a legitimate Palestinian leadership emerge—one that includes all factions, not just Western favorites.
  2. Enforce a Freeze on Israeli Settlements: No disarmament can proceed if Israel continues to build on stolen land. A total halt on settlements and settler violence must be the first step.
  3. Create an International Monitoring Mechanism: For any agreement to stick, there must be external guarantees—ideally from neutral bodies, not just U.S. or Israeli-aligned players.
  4. Let Palestinians Rule Themselves: Hamas has already shown willingness to hand over administrative control of Gaza to a unified Palestinian government. The issue is not Hamas’s grip—but Israel’s refusal to allow Palestinian unity or independence.

Gaza Is Not the Problem—Occupation Is

It must be said: Gaza didn’t create the conflict. The occupation did.

Disarming Hamas without addressing Israel’s structural violence, apartheid policies, and expansionism is not peace—it’s submission.

Israel has shown time and again that even peaceful, disarmed Palestinians are not spared. If the West Bank—quiet, demilitarized, and under the PA—is still suffering settler terrorism and mass killings, what exactly is the incentive for Gaza to disarm?

Can a Disarmed Palestine Survive Under Occupation?

Here’s the critical flaw in the current ceasefire proposals: they ask Palestinians to give up their last form of defense while offering no enforcement mechanism to stop Israeli expansion.

Without:

  • A freeze on settlements
  • A rollback of illegal outposts
  • A mechanism to stop settler violence
  • A restructured Palestinian Authority with real legitimacy

— Any ceasefire or disarmament becomes a recipe for permanent occupation.

Hamas’ weapons did not create the occupation. In fact, the occupation predates Hamas by nearly 30 years. The first Israeli settlements began in the 1970s. The military checkpoints, roadblocks, and home demolitions all existed before Hamas came into being.

So disarming Hamas doesn’t solve the root cause. It merely removes the symptom while leaving the disease to fester.

The Real Path Forward: Reform, Not Capitulation

If peace is the goal, then here’s the real path forward:

  1. Reform the Palestinian Authority — make it representative, accountable, and capable of resisting not just Israel but also corruption and fragmentation.
  2. Create enforcement mechanisms to halt and reverse Israeli settlement activity — through international pressure, sanctions, and legal consequences.
  3. Establish a UN-guaranteed demilitarized zone between Palestine and Israel, with both parties held to equal standards.
  4. Allow for democratic elections in all Palestinian territories, including Gaza, to determine the future leadership — whether it’s Hamas, Fatah, or a new technocratic government.
  5. Deploy international observers and rights monitors in the West Bank and Gaza — to document and prevent further violations.

Only after these measures are in place can we begin to talk about the voluntary, phased disarmament of Hamas, negotiated from a position of equality, not subjugation.

Final Thoughts: The Guns Are Not the Cause — They’re the Consequence

Any serious attempt at conflict resolution must ask: Why did Hamas become what it is?

It did not arise in a vacuum. It grew out of the failures of the peace process, the corruption of the PA, and the increasing militarization of the Israeli settler state.

Disarming Hamas without addressing settler colonialism will not bring peace. It will only usher in a new chapter of silent apartheid — one where Palestinians are suffocated not by bombs, but by bureaucracy, checkpoints, and broken promises.

The call to disarm Hamas might serve geopolitical optics, but it won’t serve justice or stability.

The world must stop treating the oppressed as the obstacle and start confronting the true aggressor: Israel’s settler colonialism and genocidal policies.

Until then, disarmament will remain not a step toward peace, but a surrender demand wrapped in the language of diplomacy.

As history reminds us — you can’t disarm people of hope unless you first give them justice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *