From GenAI Governance to AI-Ready Higher Education
By Zohaib Ahmed | 1st October 2026
Introduction
Generative artificial intelligence has created a structural challenge for higher education.
The issue is no longer whether students will use AI. They already can. The more important question is whether universities will redesign education around a world in which AI is permanently available.
The Higher Education Commission’s current framework on the use of Generative AI in Higher Education Institutes represents an important attempt to establish national rules for Pakistan. The framework addresses academic integrity, responsible use, transparency, informed consent, bias, privacy, accessibility, explainability, faculty development, research ethics, AI disclosure and institutional oversight. It also recognizes that universities need to review their policies as AI develops. HEC’s current webpage explicitly describes the framework as technology-agnostic and says that institutions should maintain flexibility and regularly review their policies as technological capabilities evolve.
The framework therefore addresses a real and urgent problem.
However, there is a larger question that deserves equal attention:
What happens if higher education treats AI primarily as something that must be regulated rather than as a technological force that requires the university itself to evolve?
This distinction matters.
A university can have an AI policy and still remain an AI-unready university.
It can define acceptable and unacceptable AI use. It can require disclosure. It can establish committees. It can conduct workshops. It can monitor assessments. Yet students may still graduate from an educational system designed around assumptions that AI has already made obsolete.
The challenge is therefore larger than responsible GenAI use.
It concerns the future of the university itself.
What should students learn when AI can explain concepts, generate code, summarize literature, translate languages, analyse datasets, produce presentations, generate images, draft reports, simulate interviews and increasingly perform multi-step research and administrative tasks?
What should a university assess when AI can complete many conventional assignments?
What should a research methodology course teach when AI can assist with literature discovery, coding, data analysis and writing?
What should a degree certify when graduates will enter workplaces in which AI is embedded into ordinary professional workflows?
This response paper examines the HEC framework in two interconnected ways. First, it summarizes its principal instructions and institutional expectations. Second, it evaluates the framework through an AI-ready higher education lens, particularly faculty competency, student AI literacy, assessment transformation, research workflows, institutional readiness and future technological change.
The central argument is not that academic standards should be lowered.
It is the opposite.
AI should force universities to raise the level of what they ask students to understand, verify, create, defend and apply.
Part I: What the HEC Framework Establishes
1. The framework’s purpose and scope
The HEC framework applies across universities and Degree Awarding Institutes in Pakistan and covers students, faculty, researchers, academic staff and related personnel. The downloadable HEC document describes its purpose as establishing standards for ethical GenAI use while protecting academic integrity and research authenticity.
HEC Framework on Use of Generative AI (GenAI) Tools in Higher Education Institutes (HEIs) 2026
The framework recognizes that GenAI affects teaching, learning, research and administration.
It identifies potential risks including:
- shortcut learning
- impersonation
- cheating
- misinformation
- biased outputs
- privacy and confidential-data risks
- fabricated citations
- ghostwriting
- fabricated research results
- inappropriate research automation
- plagiarism
- overdependence on AI
- erosion of critical thinking and writing skills.
This is an important starting point because GenAI is not treated as a single plagiarism problem. HEC recognizes that the technology can affect the entire academic ecosystem.
The framework also recognizes institutional responsibility. Universities are expected to establish policies, oversight mechanisms, educational initiatives, monitoring arrangements and processes for addressing misuse.
2. Core institutional responsibilities
The framework places substantial responsibility on HEIs.
Among the major areas are:
Transparency
Institutions are expected to communicate how GenAI systems are being used and provide relevant information to students and faculty.
Informed consent
Where AI systems are introduced into educational processes, institutions are expected to establish processes addressing purpose, consequences, impacts and risk.
Fairness and bias mitigation
Institutions are expected to consider potential bias and undertake appropriate auditing and mitigation, including in assessment and content generation.
Data privacy
Student and faculty information must be protected. The framework calls for data used in GenAI applications to be anonymized and treated as confidential.
Accessibility
AI systems should take into account disability, language and different user needs.
Explainability
Where AI affects educational decisions, institutions should consider transparency and understandable explanations.
These provisions establish an important governance layer.
3. Institutional committees and oversight
The framework proposes a Departmental Standing Committee with responsibilities related to GenAI governance.
These include:
- policy formulation
- oversight
- review and development of guidelines
- educational initiatives
- project and assignment review
- monitoring and audits
- coordination with relevant departments
- reporting mechanisms
- continuous policy review
- ethics training
- coordination with higher authorities
- promotion of ethical research.
The framework also calls for AI-relevant expertise within relevant institutional committees.
This is significant because AI governance cannot remain exclusively within computer science departments. A university needs educational, legal, ethical, research, information-security and disciplinary expertise.
4. Faculty and student capacity building
The framework requires or encourages institutions to conduct skills-development activities, workshops, seminars and awareness programmes.
It recognizes that faculty and staff need to understand both the capabilities and limitations of GenAI.
It also proposes integrating GenAI-related content into existing subjects such as introductory ICT and research methodology, while encouraging AI ethics and critical information literacy across disciplines.
This is directionally important.
However, the distinction between AI awareness and AI competency becomes crucial here.
Knowing that ChatGPT exists is not faculty AI competency.
Knowing how to write a prompt is not faculty AI competency.
A faculty member needs to know when AI should be used, when it should not be used, how to verify outputs, how to protect research data, how to redesign assignments, how to construct AI-aware rubrics, how to use AI for research without outsourcing scholarly judgment and how to teach students to work with AI responsibly.
UNESCO’s AI Competency Framework for Teachers provides a useful benchmark here. It identifies 15 competencies across five dimensions: human-centred mindset, ethics of AI, AI foundations and applications, AI pedagogy and AI for professional learning. These are organized into three progression levels: Acquire, Deepen and Create.
That is considerably more useful for faculty development than generic awareness training.
5. Research and academic writing
The HEC framework recognizes several legitimate applications of GenAI in research.
It identifies possible applications in:
- research design
- generating research ideas
- writing improvement
- translation
- formatting references
- quality checking.
At the same time, it warns against relying on GenAI for factual information, data generation, fabricated results and unsupported references.
The framework also requires transparent attribution of AI use.
This creates an important principle:
AI can assist the researcher, but responsibility remains with the human researcher.
That principle should become central to Pakistani research culture.
A useful operational model would be:
AI proposes.
Research databases verify.
The researcher evaluates.
The researcher cites.
The researcher remains accountable.
The problem is that this workflow is not developed in sufficient technical depth.
A modern research framework should distinguish between literature discovery, source retrieval, synthesis, methodological critique, coding, statistical analysis, visualization, translation, editing, hypothesis development and manuscript preparation.
Different AI uses carry different levels of risk.
Using AI to improve grammar is fundamentally different from using an AI agent to search literature, construct a dataset, write code, analyse the dataset and draft conclusions.
A future-ready policy needs to reflect those differences.
6. Academic integrity and assessment
Assessment is one of the most consequential parts of the framework.
HEC is concerned with unauthorized AI use, plagiarism, fabricated material and academic misconduct. The framework requires institutional rules governing AI use and disclosure. It also discusses AI-generated content, plagiarism detection and similarity thresholds.
The document also encourages institutions to develop innovative assessment methods that complement the integration of GenAI into teaching and evaluation.
This is one of the most important provisions in the framework.
But it is also where the larger transformation needs to occur.
Part II: Technical Critique Through an AI-Ready University Lens
7. The first problem: regulating AI is not the same as preparing for AI
The HEC framework is fundamentally concerned with the question:
How should universities control and govern the use of GenAI?
The next question needs to be:
How should universities change because AI exists?
These are different questions.
The first is governance.
The second is institutional transformation.
The distinction is increasingly visible internationally.
UNESCO’s student framework does not define AI education merely as learning how to use a chatbot. It identifies 12 competencies across human-centred mindset, AI ethics, AI techniques and applications, and AI system design, progressing from Understand to Apply to Create. UNESCO explicitly emphasizes that AI competency should enable students to adapt to future iterations of AI technology rather than become dependent on today’s tools.
This is the future-readiness principle that should sit underneath a national university policy.
A student should not graduate knowing how to use today’s AI application.
A student should graduate knowing how to work with changing AI systems.
That is a much more durable competency.
8. The future-readiness gap
The largest conceptual gap is therefore not necessarily a missing AI rule.
It is a missing future-readiness architecture.
AI is changing the value of university outputs.
Course content is changing.
Research methods are changing.
Writing is changing.
Programming is changing.
Design is changing.
Data analysis is changing.
Professional work is changing.
Assessment is changing.
Even the meaning of an academic assignment is changing.
If a university continues to teach students exactly what it taught before AI and then adds an AI-use policy on top, the institution has adapted its rules without necessarily adapting its educational model.
That creates a dangerous possibility.
The university can become increasingly efficient at enforcing an increasingly outdated educational model.
The question should therefore move from:
“How do we stop students from using AI?”
to:
“What capabilities should a graduate possess when AI is available?”
That question changes the entire architecture of higher education.
9. International systems are already moving beyond AI prohibition
The international evidence is important because this is not a theoretical argument.
Different education systems are experimenting with different approaches, but a common pattern is emerging: AI is increasingly being treated as a permanent component of the educational environment.
China
China’s 2026 “AI + Education” Action Plan is particularly significant.
The Ministry of Education and four other national bodies announced a plan that seeks deep integration of AI and education by 2030. At higher education level, AI is to become a public foundational course, with AI knowledge made available to students across disciplines. Universities are also being encouraged to redesign traditional programmes, create interdisciplinary AI courses, adjust academic programmes to technological and industrial change, and develop new disciplines and professional areas. The plan also explicitly connects AI to teaching, research and governance transformation.
China’s 2026 education standards also address AI application systems and AI-enabled smart campuses, including multimodal interaction and AI agents.
This is important for Pakistan because it demonstrates the difference between an AI-use policy and an AI transformation strategy.
The former governs behaviour.
The latter changes the institution.
South Korea
South Korea provides another useful example.
In 2026, its Ministry of Education and the Korean Council for University Education selected 20 universities for a national AI basic curriculum programme. The initiative aims to give students fundamental AI competencies regardless of major.
Participating universities are developing foundational AI liberal-arts courses, AI applications for non-engineering disciplines and faculty AI-capacity programmes. The government is supporting the selected universities financially and requiring curriculum sharing to spread the resulting models.
This directly supports a principle that should be stronger in Pakistan:
AI literacy should not belong exclusively to computer science students.
A lawyer will work with AI.
A doctor will work with AI.
A teacher will work with AI.
An economist will work with AI.
A journalist will work with AI.
A researcher will work with AI.
A business graduate will work with AI.
The question is therefore not whether every student should become an AI engineer.
It is whether every graduate should possess sufficient AI literacy to function responsibly and effectively in an AI-mediated professional environment.
Taiwan
Taiwan offers another model.
The Taiwan Artificial Intelligence College Alliance has expanded to 55 universities. It uses cross-institutional course delivery and credit recognition to help students outside AI-related disciplines build interdisciplinary AI capabilities while addressing shortages of specialized faculty.
The lesson is institutional.
AI readiness does not necessarily require every university to independently build every capability.
Universities can share courses.
They can share faculty.
They can share infrastructure.
They can develop cross-institutional programmes.
They can create common competency standards.
This is especially relevant to Pakistan, where differences in institutional resources are substantial.
Singapore
Singapore provides perhaps the clearest example of the assessment question.
At the National University of Singapore, educators have been actively redesigning assessment around GenAI. NUS guidance argues that when AI is part of the authentic environment in which a task would actually be performed, its use may be permitted or encouraged. It also recommends testing assessment questions against current GenAI systems when AI access is allowed.
NUS researchers and educators have also explored AI-infused assignments, peer review, contextual tasks and other forms of assessment that emphasize what students can do beyond simply producing a polished written answer.
Nanyang Technological University has gone further by offering a dedicated course, Assessment in the Generative AI Age, examining how GenAI changes assessment while retaining core principles of educational assessment.
This is a fundamentally different mindset.
Instead of asking only whether AI should be allowed, the institution asks:
What should the assessment measure now?
That is the question Pakistan’s higher education system needs to confront.
The United States
The United States also provides examples of universities treating AI as an assessment-design problem rather than solely an integrity problem.
Arizona State University, for example, provides guidance asking instructors to start with learning outcomes and determine what evidence of learning they need to collect in an AI-rich environment.
MIT similarly identifies three possible approaches to AI in assessment: require it, allow it or ban it, depending on the learning outcome and assessment purpose.
At the University of Pennsylvania, instructors are being encouraged to use AI to create and modify assessments, including question banks and differentiated levels of difficulty.
This is important.
AI does not only threaten assessment.
AI can also become part of the assessment infrastructure.
10. The assessment model needs to change
This is perhaps the most important technical recommendation arising from the entire discussion.
Universities should stop treating every conventional assignment as though its original purpose remains unchanged after the arrival of AI.
Suppose a student is asked to write a 2,000-word paper explaining a topic.
If AI can produce a competent 2,000-word explanation within seconds, the existence of AI has changed the assessment environment.
The answer should not automatically be to ban AI.
Instead, the university should ask:
What are we actually trying to assess?
If the learning outcome is information retrieval and basic explanation, AI may be permitted.
If the learning outcome is critical analysis, the task should require analysis.
If the learning outcome is research competence, the student should demonstrate research.
If the learning outcome is argumentation, the student should defend an argument.
If the learning outcome is communication, the student should present.
If the learning outcome is professional judgment, the student should make and defend decisions.
If the learning outcome is source evaluation, the student should verify sources.
The assessment should therefore become harder in the right dimension.
11. Give students AI, then raise the standard
This is where higher education can move beyond the binary of “AI allowed” versus “AI prohibited.”
A university could say:
Use AI.
But then require the student to:
- identify the research question;
- formulate the prompt or research strategy;
- obtain primary and secondary sources;
- verify every important claim;
- identify weaknesses in the AI response;
- correct factual or logical errors;
- cite the original sources;
- explain why particular evidence was selected;
- compare competing interpretations;
- revise the AI-generated draft;
- disclose the AI contribution;
- present the final argument orally;
- answer questions from an examiner;
- defend methodological decisions.
Now AI becomes part of the academic process without becoming a substitute for academic judgment.
This is much closer to the real professional world.
A lawyer does not receive a promotion because they can type faster than an AI.
A researcher does not become valuable because they can produce 5,000 words.
An engineer does not become valuable because AI can generate code.
A consultant does not become valuable because an AI can make a PowerPoint.
The human value increasingly lies in problem definition, judgment, verification, contextual understanding, communication, responsibility and decision-making.
Assessment needs to measure those things.
12. The return of the peer-review system
There is another opportunity that deserves much greater attention.
AI may actually provide an opportunity to revive serious peer review at undergraduate and postgraduate levels.
Instead of asking students only to submit a final paper, universities could introduce a research-production cycle:
Research question → proposal → source collection → first draft → peer review → AI-assisted revision → second draft → instructor review → final submission → oral defence.
This changes the assignment from a product into a process.
A student could be required to submit:
- research question;
- bibliography;
- source verification log;
- initial argument;
- AI interaction disclosure;
- peer-review comments;
- response to peer review;
- revised paper;
- final reflection.
The final paper would still matter.
But it would no longer be the only evidence.
This is particularly important because AI makes the final polished product less reliable as the sole indicator of individual learning.
TEQSA’s 2026 assessment work similarly emphasizes proactive assessment redesign, authentic assessment, AI literacy, evidence-based verification and continuous review rather than relying primarily on detection.
13. Oral defence should return to higher education
The oral defence should also become more common.
This does not mean turning every assignment into a viva.
It means using oral interaction strategically where authentic understanding matters.
A student who submits a research paper could be asked:
Why did you select this source?
Why did you reject another interpretation?
What is the weakest part of your argument?
What did the AI get wrong?
What would change your conclusion?
How did you verify this statistic?
Why did you select this methodology?
What would you do differently if you repeated the research?
These questions are much harder to outsource.
More importantly, they measure something universities actually care about:
Does the student understand the work they submitted?
Research and practice internationally increasingly point toward oral, contextual, process-based and authentic assessment as part of the response to GenAI. NUS, Monash and TEQSA are all developing assessment approaches that focus on learning evidence, contextual judgment, oral communication, process and authentic capabilities.
14. AI detection is not a future-ready assessment strategy
The HEC framework’s treatment of plagiarism and AI detection deserves particular technical scrutiny.
There is an important distinction between:
text similarity detection
and
AI-generation detection.
They are not the same measurement.
Similarity software identifies overlap between a submission and existing sources.
AI detectors attempt to estimate whether text was generated by an AI system.
Those measurements answer different questions.
The international direction increasingly cautions against making AI detection the basis of academic decisions.
The University of Oxford states that it does not endorse digital AI detectors for academic decision-making because current tools cannot reliably establish whether AI was used.
The University of Queensland disabled Turnitin’s AI writing indicator from Semester 2, 2025 and explicitly describes AI detection tools as flawed and unreliable.
Monash University likewise states that AI detection tools are not approved as evidence for suspected academic misconduct, citing reliability, privacy, equity and data-security concerns.
This has a direct implication for Pakistan.
The question should not be:
“Can software tell us whether this student used AI?”
The better question is:
“Can our assessment provide credible evidence that this student understands and can defend the learning outcome?”
That is a much stronger academic standard.
15. The 19 percent issue requires clarification
The HEC document also contains a technically problematic formulation around AI-generated content and the 19 percent similarity threshold.
The framework refers to plagiarism-detection software and a 19 percent overall similarity threshold while discussing AI-generated text.
This creates a conceptual problem.
A similarity percentage is not an AI-use percentage.
A paper can have 5 percent similarity and still be extensively generated by AI.
A paper can have 25 percent similarity because it contains correctly quoted, referenced or conventional material and still represent legitimate scholarly work.
The measurement must therefore match the phenomenon being measured.
Similarity measures textual overlap.
AI detection estimates AI involvement.
Neither independently measures learning.
A future-ready assessment framework should therefore avoid treating any numerical similarity score as a proxy for academic authenticity.
16. Research needs an AI-native workflow
The HEC framework correctly identifies risks around fabricated citations, research automation and fabricated results.
But the research workflow needs to be redesigned in much greater detail.
An AI-ready research methodology should teach students and researchers to use AI through a controlled workflow:
Stage 1: Question formation
Human researcher defines the problem.
Stage 2: Literature discovery
AI can assist discovery, but sources must be retrieved from legitimate databases.
Stage 3: Source verification
Every important citation is opened and checked.
Stage 4: Literature analysis
AI can assist comparison and synthesis, but researchers inspect the original studies.
Stage 5: Methodology
The researcher determines the appropriate research design.
Stage 6: Data
AI can assist with coding and analysis, but the researcher remains responsible for data integrity.
Stage 7: Interpretation
AI may identify patterns or alternative explanations, but the researcher determines what the evidence actually supports.
Stage 8: Writing
AI may assist with drafting, language or structure where permitted.
Stage 9: Verification
Claims, numbers, citations, quotations and references are checked.
Stage 10: Human accountability
The researcher signs off on the final work.
This is a more useful concept of responsible AI than simply declaring that AI was used.
17. AI literacy should become a graduate competency
HEC’s framework recognizes AI literacy as important.
The next step should be to make the concept measurable.
Every graduate should leave university with the ability to:
Understand AI systems.
Use AI tools responsibly.
Question AI outputs.
Create with AI.
Govern AI use.
This is different from teaching a single AI course.
AI literacy should exist at three levels.
Level 1: Foundational AI literacy
All students should understand:
- what AI systems are;
- what GenAI does;
- hallucinations;
- bias;
- privacy;
- intellectual property;
- misinformation;
- synthetic media;
- responsible use;
- source verification.
Level 2: Discipline-specific AI literacy
Students should understand how AI affects their field.
A medical student needs different AI competencies from an architecture student.
A law student needs different competencies from a computer scientist.
A business student needs different competencies from a historian.
Level 3: Advanced AI practice
Selected students should develop deeper competencies in:
- machine learning;
- data science;
- robotics;
- AI agents;
- automation;
- AI research;
- AI governance;
- AI engineering.
This creates a system in which every student has AI literacy without requiring every student to become an AI engineer.
18. Faculty development must move from awareness to capability
Faculty development presents another major opportunity.
A one-off seminar about ChatGPT will not prepare a university for AI.
Faculty need a progression model.
UNESCO’s Acquire, Deepen and Create progression provides a useful foundation.
A university could therefore establish:
Acquire
Faculty understand AI capabilities, limitations, ethics and basic academic applications.
Deepen
Faculty redesign lectures, research workflows, assignments and assessments using AI appropriately.
Create
Faculty develop AI-enabled courses, assessment models, research methodologies and new learning experiences.
This should be discipline-specific.
An AI workshop for an English department should not be identical to one for medicine, engineering, business or social sciences.
Faculty development should therefore move from:
AI awareness → AI practice → course transformation → assessment transformation → curriculum transformation.
19. Curriculum transformation is larger than GenAI
The HEC framework focuses primarily on GenAI.
Future university policy needs to anticipate the broader AI stack.
The next generation of academic disruption will not be limited to chatbots.
Universities will increasingly encounter:
- AI agents;
- autonomous research assistants;
- multimodal AI;
- AI coding systems;
- computer-use systems;
- AI tutors;
- AI-generated simulations;
- synthetic media;
- intelligent laboratories;
- AI-assisted scientific discovery;
- automated data analysis;
- AI-enabled administrative systems;
- human-AI collaborative research.
China’s 2026 education standards already explicitly discuss AI agents and multimodal interaction within AI-enabled smart campuses.
This is why a policy built around today’s chatbot category can become outdated quickly.
The durable unit of policy should therefore be the competency and workflow, not the tool.
20. The university itself is the thing that needs to adapt
There is a deeper institutional issue.
If AI can perform a growing portion of what universities currently package as coursework, then universities must reconsider what they are selling.
A degree cannot remain primarily a certificate that a student successfully consumed information and reproduced it in examinations.
The university needs to become a place where students learn to:
Think → Understand → Research → Create → Build → Collaborate → Verify → Solve → Present → Defend.
That represents a shift from:
Learn → Memorise → Reproduce → Submit → Examine
towards:
Understand → Investigate → Analyse → Create → Apply → Present → Defend.
AI makes this transition more urgent.
The objective should not be to protect obsolete academic tasks from AI.
The objective should be to identify which human capabilities become more valuable because AI exists.
21. Assessment should distinguish between AI-required, AI-permitted and AI-restricted work
A mature university AI policy should not use one rule for every assignment.
It should create categories.
AI-required
Students must use AI and document how they used it.
Example:
Use an AI system to produce three policy proposals. Identify weaknesses, verify evidence and defend your final recommendation.
AI-permitted
Students may use AI, but must disclose its use.
Example:
Use AI for brainstorming or language editing, while remaining responsible for research and final analysis.
AI-restricted
AI is not permitted because the assessment is measuring an independent capability.
Example:
A supervised examination designed to test foundational mathematical reasoning.
AI-independent evidence
The student must demonstrate understanding without AI assistance.
This could involve:
- oral defence;
- supervised practical work;
- live problem-solving;
- laboratory demonstration;
- presentation;
- coding demonstration;
- viva;
- in-class writing.
This model is much more precise than a general “AI allowed” or “AI prohibited” policy.
22. The assessment should become harder where AI is strong
This is perhaps the most important principle.
If AI is extremely good at producing generic explanations, stop rewarding generic explanations.
If AI can write an essay, require students to critique an essay.
If AI can summarize five papers, require students to compare the methodologies of those papers.
If AI can generate a business plan, require students to defend the assumptions behind it.
If AI can write code, require students to test, debug, explain and modify the code.
If AI can generate a research proposal, require students to defend the methodology.
If AI can produce a presentation, require the student to present and answer questions.
The objective is not to make assessment artificially difficult.
It is to make assessment educationally valid.
Recent TEQSA guidance makes a similar case for assessment adaptation that focuses on learning outcomes, authentic engagement, critical thinking, ethical reasoning and continuous review.
23. Future readiness should become an institutional KPI
A national framework should eventually move beyond asking whether a university has an AI policy.
It should ask whether the university is becoming AI-ready.
Possible indicators include:
- percentage of faculty completing AI competency development;
- percentage of programmes with AI competency mapping;
- percentage of courses with explicit AI-use policies;
- percentage of assessments reviewed for AI vulnerability;
- percentage of programmes using process-based assessment;
- student AI literacy measurement;
- faculty AI competency measurement;
- research-AI governance compliance;
- AI data-protection compliance;
- number of interdisciplinary AI courses;
- availability of AI-supported learning infrastructure;
- industry collaboration;
- peer-review and oral-defence adoption;
- annual assessment redesign;
- annual AI policy review.
This converts AI policy from a document into an institutional improvement system.
24. Pakistan needs an AI-ready university architecture
The Pakistani context requires special consideration.
Universities differ enormously in:
- faculty capacity;
- funding;
- infrastructure;
- internet access;
- device availability;
- student socioeconomic conditions;
- language;
- class size;
- research capacity;
- institutional maturity.
A national framework therefore needs minimum standards but should also allow tiered implementation.
A university with limited resources cannot be expected to replicate the infrastructure of a major research institution.
However, every institution should be able to establish minimum competencies around:
AI literacy.
Academic integrity.
Verification.
Privacy.
Responsible use.
Assessment redesign.
Faculty development.
Research integrity.
The system should also encourage collaboration between universities so that high-quality AI courses, faculty expertise and learning resources can be shared.
Taiwan’s cross-university AI course model provides one possible reference point for this type of architecture.
25. From “AI-resistant” to “AI-ready”
The distinction between AI-resistant and AI-ready education deserves explicit attention.
An AI-resistant assignment asks:
How can I prevent the student from using AI?
An AI-ready assignment asks:
How can I use the existence of AI to make this learning experience more meaningful?
An AI-resistant university spends substantial energy trying to determine whether AI touched the student’s work.
An AI-ready university asks students to demonstrate what they did with AI, what AI got wrong, what evidence they verified and what decisions they made themselves.
An AI-resistant system protects the old assessment.
An AI-ready system redesigns the assessment.
An AI-resistant curriculum teaches knowledge and adds AI rules.
An AI-ready curriculum asks how the discipline itself is changing because of AI.
That is the transition Pakistan needs to consider.
Conclusion
The HEC framework establishes an important governance foundation for the responsible use of Generative AI in Pakistani higher education.
It recognizes academic integrity risks, research risks, privacy, bias, transparency, informed consent, institutional oversight, faculty development, AI disclosure and continuous policy review. It also recognizes that AI can support teaching, research and administration.
The next stage, however, needs to move beyond responsible use toward AI-ready higher education.
The central issue is no longer simply whether students are using AI.
They are entering a world in which AI will increasingly be embedded in the tools through which they study, research and work.
That means the university itself must evolve.
If a traditional essay can be generated in seconds, the answer is not necessarily to defend the traditional essay.
If AI can answer conventional examination questions, the answer is not necessarily to make students hide from AI.
If AI can assist research, the answer is not to isolate researchers from it.
The answer is to change what counts as evidence of learning.
Students should be able to use AI where appropriate.
But they should also be required to demonstrate higher levels of judgment.
They should verify sources.
They should detect errors.
They should distinguish evidence from plausible language.
They should conduct research.
They should cite original sources.
They should revise.
They should collaborate.
They should present.
They should defend.
They should explain what they did and why.
They should understand the limitations of the systems they use.
This is not a lowering of academic standards.
It is a redefinition of academic standards for an AI-mediated world.
International examples already demonstrate that this transition is underway. China is redesigning university curricula and academic structures around AI. South Korea is expanding foundational AI education across disciplines. Taiwan is building cross-university AI education networks. Singapore is actively redesigning assessment and creating dedicated academic study of assessment in the GenAI era. Universities in the United States are experimenting with AI-aware assessment design. UNESCO has developed competency frameworks that move beyond tool use toward human-centred, ethical, critical and creative AI capabilities.
The lesson for Pakistan is therefore broader than “allow AI” or “ban AI.”
The real question is:
What should a Pakistani university produce when intelligence itself has become increasingly accessible through machines?
The answer should be graduates who are difficult to replace because they can do what AI alone cannot reliably do.
They can understand context.
They can question evidence.
They can make judgments.
They can conduct research.
They can identify uncertainty.
They can work with people.
They can collaborate with machines.
They can create.
They can defend their decisions.
They can take responsibility.
The principle should be simple:
Technology should increase human capability without replacing human judgment.
That principle also provides a useful way to interpret the future of assessment.
AI should not automatically make academic work less demanding.
It should allow universities to demand more.
A student who uses AI to draft a paper should be able to explain the argument.
A student who uses AI to analyse data should understand the methodology.
A student who uses AI to generate code should be able to debug and defend it.
A student who uses AI to research should verify every important source.
A student who submits a paper should be able to present and defend it.
A student who uses AI should know where AI ends and their own responsibility begins.
The university of the future will therefore not be the institution that successfully prevents AI from entering the classroom.
It will be the institution that understands what human learning should look like after AI has entered the classroom.
For Pakistan, the HEC framework can become the governance layer for that transition. The next requirement is an implementation architecture that connects policy with faculty competency, student AI literacy, curriculum redesign, research practice, assessment reform, institutional capability and continuous technological foresight.
That is the difference between having an AI policy and building an AI-ready university.
Professional contribution
This transition also creates a practical need for institutional capacity building. Universities cannot implement AI-ready education through policy documents alone. Faculty need practical training in AI-assisted teaching, research, assessment, prompt engineering, verification, academic integrity and curriculum redesign. Academic leaders also need institution-level consultation on AI policy, faculty development, assessment strategy, research workflows and longer-term AI-readiness planning.
I am available for paid institutional AI faculty training, customized faculty development workshops and higher-level university consultations across Pakistan, with programmes designed around the institution’s discipline mix, faculty capability, existing AI policy, assessment model and strategic objectives.
The objective is not to teach faculty how to use one AI tool.
The objective is to help universities move from AI awareness to AI practice, from AI practice to course transformation, and from course transformation to an AI-ready academic system.
Selected references
Higher Education Commission Pakistan. Framework on Use of Generative AI (GenAI) Tools in Higher Education Institutes (HEIs), Version 1.0.
UNESCO. AI Competency Framework for Teachers. 2024.
UNESCO. AI Competency Framework for Students. 2024.
Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency. Adapting Assessment in the Age of Generative AI: The Assessment Adaptation Model. 2026.
Tertiary Education Quality and Standards Agency. New Resource for Gen AI and Assurances of Learning. 2026.
Ministry of Education of the People’s Republic of China. AI + Education Action Plan. 2026.
Ministry of Education, Republic of Korea. 2026 University AI Basic Curriculum Development Support Project. 2026.
Ministry of Education, Republic of China (Taiwan). Taiwan Artificial Intelligence College Alliance.
National University of Singapore. Rethinking Assessment in the Age of GenAI.
Nanyang Technological University. Assessment in the Generative AI Age.
University of Oxford. The Question of AI Detection. 2026.
University of Queensland. AI Detection and Assessment.
Monash University. AI and Assessment. 2026.
